Listen to the recording again and answer these questions.
Caractaran | Characters
Cia mheud caractar a tha a’ nochdadh san sgeulachd agus cò iad?
How many characters appear in the story and who are they?
Suidheachadh | Situation
Càit a bheil an sgeulachd stèidhichte?
Where is the story set?
Cuspairean is teachdaireachd | Themes and message
Dè na prìomh chuspairean air a bheil Mac a’ Ghobhainn a’ togail agus dè an teachdaireachd a th’ aige no an leasan a th’ ann dhuinn?
What are the main themes that Smith raises, and what message or lesson is he trying to convey to us?
Agus seo dhut freagairtean!
And here are some answers!
Cia mheud caractar a tha a’ nochdadh san sgeulachd agus cò iad?
Tha Iain Mac a’ Ghobhainn an toiseach a’ cur an cèill cho eadar-dhealaichte ‘s a tha an dà charactar, a’ chailleach agus an duine dubh.
Iain Mac a’ Ghobhainn first expresses how different the two characters are, the old woman and an duine dubh (the black man).
Càit a bheil an sgeulachd stèidhichte?
‘S dòcha gu bheil sinn an dùil an toiseach gur ann ann am baile beag Gàidhealach a tha an sgeulachd stèidhichte. Ach gheibh sinn a-mach aig an deireadh gur ann anns a’ bhaile-mhòr a tha an sgeulachd stèidhichte.
We might first expect that the story is set in a small Highland village. But we find out at the end that it’s set in the city.
Dè na prìomh chuspairean air a bheil Mac a’ Ghobhainn a’ togail agus dè an teachdaireachd a th’ aige no an leasan a th’ ann dhuinn?
Fhad ‘s a tha an sgeulachd a’ dol air adhart tha a’ chailleach a’ sealltainn tuigse agus co-fhaireachdainn ris an duine dhubh, mus ionnsaich sinn aig an deireadh gur e coigrich aonranach a th’ anns an dithis aca anns a’ bhaile-mhòr, fada bhon dachaigh agus bhon daoine fhèin. ‘S e an teachdaireachd: tùsanach no coigreach, eilthireach no in-imriche, bochd no beairteach, tha sinn uile co-ionann.
As the story continues the old woman shows understanding and sympathy with an duine dubh, before we learn at the end that they are both lonely strangers in the city, far from home and people. The message is that: native or stranger, emigrant or immigrant, rich or poor, we are all equal.
An do chòrd an sgeulachd riut?
Did you like the story?
A bheil thu a’ smaoineachadh gu bheil tiotal na sgeulachd freagarrach san latha a th’ ann?
Do you think that the story title is appropriate nowadays?
A bheil do bheachd air atharrachadh bho thoiseach na sgeulachd?
Has your opinion changed from the beginning of the story?
Ciamar a tha na caractaran coltach ri chèile aig deireadh na sgeulachd?
How are the characters similar at the end of the story?